Quick answer
Sandy Island Anguilla is a unique dining establishment situated on a sandbar in Sandy Ground, The Valley 2640, Anguilla, with the specific address at 6V7J+2PJ. This restaurant offers an extraordinary setting where guests can enjoy meals and drinks while surrounded by the Caribbean Sea, creating an intimate and secluded beach experience. The establishment has garnered a mixed reception with a Google rating of 3.7 stars based on 36 reviews, indicating a polarizing experience among visitors. Some patrons praise the exceptional ambiance and the quality of certain offerings, while others criticize the service speed and staff attitude, suggesting that the experience can vary significantly depending on when you visit and who serves you. The restaurant's most distinctive feature is its location on a sandbar, which provides a truly unique dining environment that has surprised many guests who question how the structure remains intact despite the surrounding sea. This setting offers a secluded beach and bar experience that some reviewers describe as "all to yourself," particularly during certain times of day or seasons. The menu features Caribbean-inspired cuisine and beverages, with the rum punch being specifically highlighted by one reviewer as the best they had during their time in Anguilla. Despite its picturesque location, the restaurant appears to operate with limited staff, which may contribute to service inconsistencies that have been noted in multiple reviews. GUEST EXPERIENCE: Guest experiences at Sandy Island Anguilla appear to be divided into two distinct camps: those who have an exceptional time and those who leave frustrated. Positive reviews frequently mention the magical atmosphere of dining on a sandbar, with one guest stating they "absolutely loved it" and had "a time" during their visit, particularly noting the quiet, intimate setting with music and flowing drinks. These satisfied customers often emphasize the great service, friendly and helpful staff, and the unique opportunity to have a secluded beach and bar experience all to themselves. The Mother's Day weekend visit that resulted in a perfect 5-star review suggests that certain times may offer better service and atmosphere than others. Conversely, negative reviews paint a starkly different picture, highlighting significant service issues and mediocre food quality. One particularly critical review mentions waiting three hours for food, forcing the guest to go up to the bar themselves to get drinks, and describing the service as "sucks" with a zero-star rating. Another reviewer specifically calls out "rude and unwelcoming people who work at restaurant," indicating that staff attitude may be inconsistent. While some guests acknowledge that the price is justified by the unique location, others feel the food quality doesn't match the premium pricing, especially when combined with already included service charges and additional tipping requests. These conflicting experiences suggest that the restaurant's quality may be highly dependent on factors like timing, staffing levels, or specific staff members on duty.
In their own words
“I absolutely loved it!!!!! Went with my gf’s we had a time. Got there an hour after the island opened and left when the crew left. It’s a must. Quiet, intimate, music, food, drinks flowing. I have no complaints. Secluded beach and bar all to yourself!!!!! Service was great, staff friendly and helpful!!!What more you want?!!! I went around Mother’s Day weekend and would do it again!!!! If you get there when the staff gets there yes you have to wait for food to be cooked it’s fresh. So take drink, take a dip in the water and relax!!! I’m so happy I got to experience this!!!!”
“The atmosphere of this place is pretty cool. You’re pretty much at a restaurant on a sandbar. I am surprised this place hasn’t been washed away by the sea. Our food was good and the rum punch was the best I had in Anguilla. The food is pricey and I’m pretty sure I was asked for a tip even though a service charge was already included but the price was worth the location.”
“The food was very mediocre, and it took us 3 hours to get it. The service sucks, and I had to go up to the bar myself to get drinks. Unless you like waiting 3 hours, please don't come here because we had, and everyone around me took 3 hours for food. I would give the service zero stars.”
Location
6V7J+2PJ, Sandy Ground, The Valley 2640, Anguilla
Good to know
What type of business is Sandy Island Anguilla?+
Sandy Island Anguilla is listed as a restaurant in Anguilla.
Where is Sandy Island Anguilla located?+
Sandy Island Anguilla is located at 6V7J+2PJ, Sandy Ground, The Valley 2640, Anguilla.
What is the guest rating of Sandy Island Anguilla?+
Sandy Island Anguilla has a rating of 3.7/5 from 36 Google reviews.
More places to eat
